Any regular reader of the PIBlawg will be aware that I have an interest in fraudulent personal injury claims, being involved as I am in numerous cases where a vast range of fraud is alleged by Defendant parties (also see http://bit.ly/1vRcuWT; http://bit.ly/1znwXHI; http://bit.ly/1GokHKm).
In recent years there appears to have been a change in culture of insurers, who are far more prepared to fight claims on the basis of that they are fraudulent. There have been many high-profile news articles suggesting that fraudulent road traffic accidents cost each motor insurance policy holder up to £100, but this is falling due to the rise in claims being run to trial alleging foul play: a pour encourager les autres approach?
The courts too appear now more prepared to commit PI fraudsters to prison, but recently the police and CPS stepped in to prosecute a man who deliberately “slipped” on a wet bag in a supermarket. Waheed Iqbal was seen on CCTV feigning a slip of a Lidl store in Bradford which is well worth a watch on the BBC website at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-30352231.
At trial at Bradford and Keighley Magistrates’ Court, he was found guilty of two counts of fraud by false representation. He was sentenced at Bradford Crown Court to a 10-month jail sentence, suspended for two years.
The CCTV shows Mr Iqbal was wheeled out of the Lidl store to an ambulance but it is reported that an insurance fraud investigation team later found he asked the paramedics to stop before they reached hospital, alighting the vehicle unaided and returning straight back to the Lidl store to request the incident was reported.
It seemed that this may not have been Mr Iqbal’s first attempt at a false PI claim. The BBC reported that Police also discovered he staged another “accident” with a punchbag in a gym so he could make a PI claim.
This case must also represent another risk to would-be fraudulent PI litigants: even if for commercial reasons a committal is not pursued by a defendant insurer at the successful conclusion of a trial where fraud is found, the matter may well be taken up by the CPS.